Top Roofing Service Pros in Caldwell, Idaho

Idaho Roofing Contractors stands out for their excellent communication, professionalism, and high-quality work. Customers appreciate quick service, thorough inspections, and competitive pricing. The team, particularly individuals like Andrew and Will, is noted for their responsiveness and helpfulness throughout the roofing process, leading to highly recommended experiences.

Some customers express dissatisfaction with Idaho Roofing Contractors due to concerns about work quality and communication. A few reviews mention high quotes compared to competitors, while others report unexpected costs and poorly executed repairs. Additionally, there are mentions of pushy staff and questions regarding the company's integrity.

Signature Roofing is highly praised for its commitment to community service and exceptional quality in roofing. Customers appreciate their professionalism, reliability, and dedication to customer satisfaction, making them a trusted choice in the industry.

Some customers have noted issues with customer service responsiveness and long wait times. A handful of reviews mention dissatisfaction with product quality, citing inconsistencies in performance. Additionally, several users expressed concerns about unclear return policies, which may lead to confusion.

Treasure Valley Exteriors stands out for its professional service, high-quality installations, and exceptional communication. Customers appreciate the promptness and expertise of the staff, as well as their ability to navigate insurance processes smoothly. Many commend the attention to detail and efficient handling of projects, resulting in beautiful home transformations.

Some customers have reported issues with long delays, poor communication, and unsatisfactory work quality at Treasure Valley Exteriors. A number of reviews highlight installation errors, unresolved project issues, and a lack of accountability from the company. Additionally, concerns about aggressive sales tactics and unprofessional behavior have contributed to negative experiences.

Customers consistently praise New Castle Installs for their thorough inspections, professionalism, and exceptional customer service. The team is recognized for clear communication, fast installations, and comprehensive explanations of options. Many reviewers highlight the integrity and knowledge of the staff, making the roofing process smooth and stress-free, leading to high recommendations for their services.

Some customers report unsatisfactory door-to-door solicitation practices and rudeness in communication. Issues with poor project management, delays, and lack of follow-up after contracts have also been mentioned. A handful express frustration over high-pressure sales tactics and concerns about work quality, leading to feelings of being neglected or scammed post-sale.

Consumers consistently praise Bartlett Homes and Roofing for their excellent communication, professional service, and efficient roof installations. Many highlight the team's expertise in navigating insurance claims and providing thorough inspections. Customers appreciate the compassionate support and quick resolution of issues, resulting in a smooth roofing process and high-quality workmanship.

Some customers express frustration with Bartlett Roofing over poor communication and work quality, noting issues with billing and delays. A handful of reviews mention aggressive sales tactics and unwanted solicitation. Additionally, some report problems with roof leaks and unresolved debris, leading to a generally negative experience despite occasional praise for the actual roofing quality.

E & H Roofing is highly praised for their excellent communication, timely service, and quality workmanship. Customers appreciate the professionalism and attentiveness of the staff, as well as their ability to handle challenging repair issues efficiently. Many noted competitive pricing and a smooth experience from initial consultation to project completion.

Some customers have noted concerns regarding E&H's roofing service, mentioning issues with workmanship and professionalism despite high prices. A handful of reviews indicate missed appointments, contributing to a less favorable impression of the company's reliability.

Rooftops Energy Solutions stands out for its exceptional customer service, clear communication, and high-quality craftsmanship. Clients appreciate the professionalism and efficiency of the team, with many praising their honest assessments and fair pricing. The company's ability to handle various roofing projects with minimal mess and timely completion has earned them strong recommendations from satisfied customers.

Some customers express disappointment regarding leaking roofs after replacements, citing concerns about workmanship. A handful of reviews mention dissatisfaction with warranty service and perceived lack of accountability from the company. These aspects may be worth considering for prospective clients.

Western Roofing is praised for its prompt service, providing quick estimates and delivering high-quality workmanship. Customers highlight the company's effectiveness in resolving long-standing leak issues, which showcases their expertise and reliability.

Some customers have noted concerns about the company's licensing status, specifically mentioning that it is no longer licensed to operate in Oregon. This has raised questions about its legitimacy and reliability among a handful of reviews.

Rebel Roofing is highly praised for its excellent communication, professional service, and quality workmanship. Customers appreciate the competitive pricing, timely project completion, and meticulous cleanup. The team's expertise and honesty during assessments stand out, making them a top choice for roofing needs in the community.

Some customers have noted delays in shipping and occasional issues with product quality. A handful of reviews mention customer service experiences that could be improved, particularly regarding response times. Additionally, a few users expressed concerns about pricing not aligning with their expectations based on product descriptions.

Straightline Design LLC is highly praised for its professionalism, competitive pricing, and excellent communication. Customers appreciate the thorough cleanup after projects and the team's ethical, efficient service. The company is noted for delivering quality work, particularly in metal roof installations, and for assisting clients with insurance processes.

Some customers have reported frustrating experiences with subcontractors during roof replacements, citing debris issues and delays. Communication has also been a concern, with a handful of reviews mentioning excessive follow-ups and unclear costs, leading to dissatisfaction with the overall responsiveness and project timelines.